Skip to main content

Could IRS or California come after me somehow? I'm a resident alien with non-US permanent address on W8.

This is a complex post but it's crucial for my survival (I'm from a destabilized country) so I wanted to give all the relevant details. Thanks in advance for your advice

I left US before becoming a tax resident [0]. I never filled out any tax related forms other than W8. I didn't pay any taxes to the IRS. I didn't earn any income when I was in the US. I didn't have a SSN.

My US bank accounts are still open. Also credit cards. No issues so far.

I am categorized as a resident alien in bank's system. My last CA address is on file so I am categorized as a US resident. This is not true obviously but I was suggested to do this [1].

My permanent address on bank's system is a US address but my permanent address listed on W8 is a non-US address. Maybe this is what counts as far as IRS and California is concerned? This is also my mailing address. Banks send W8 once a year here.

My US and non-US phone numbers are in the system. Not sure if this is relevant? Sometimes I heard it could be relevant. E.g Canada claims you still owe them taxes even after you move your residency elsewhere because you didn't close down your phone number. They use it as an evidence of ties, and they use the ties to prove you are still a tax resident in Canada, but this is for citizens I believe. Point is if a country can use phone number to tax you, I guess they could also use being categorized as a resident to tax you?

Obviously US has my records of entering and leaving the country and they can see how many days I spent in US each year and they can see which visa I was on so they can determine I wasn't a tax resident, I think

[0] Students under an F, J, M, or Q status are exempt from counting days for five years for Substantial Presence Test. Which was the case for me.

[1] I talked to two bank tellers from different bank branches before I left US. They suggested me I could just leave the address as is. They told about some other students who came back to US after 6 years who did the same thing without issues. But not sure if this is the correct advice.
Also on the internet I see that expats suggest each other to not change their permanent address to a non-US one. But they are not aliens. And maybe they're applying for FEIE, to tell IRS that they are not a US tax resident (despite the banks categorizing them as a US resident). FEIE is also only for US persons.

So that's the situation.

1) Can this cause me some tax obligation or any legal issues in any way in the future? Can IRS or California tax me somehow or cause me any trouble? I don't plan to go back to the US but I might visit as a tourist. Highly unlikely but I might move back on H1B or E2 or EB5. I want to be able to keep money there without any concerns. That's my main goal.

2) After leaving US, I created US brokerage accounts, remotely, with ONLY non-US address. My banking history cannot cause me any trouble with my brokers in any way, right? E.g Maybe IRS and CA thinks I'm a US resident because that's how I'm categorized by my banks (despite the W8 including my permanent non-US address). So they want me to pay taxes on my capital gains that originate from my brokerage account somehow?

3) If I move my money from my broker to my bank, could that cause any problems in the future? Maybe CA or IRS assumes its income and since I'm a "US resident", they can demand tax? Maybe I appear as a tax evader or avoider in CA or IRS' system already and they are waiting for the interest to fatten up and after 10 years maybe they will directly take their cut from my bank or brokerage accounts automatically?

4) As far as I know, money transferring between your own accounts do not create any taxable event, Bank <> bank, broker <> broker, bank <> broker, regardless of the jurisdictions. --- I can get paid from a US business to my US bank account and I wouldn't owe any taxes to the US since I'm not a tax resident there (assuming being categorized as a US resident by my bank doesn't make me US resident). --- I do not owe any taxes to US on capital gains on my US brokerage account, it's only for dividends. --- Anything I'm missing? Asking just in case

submitted by /u/panic_aaaaa
[link] [comments]


Popular posts from this blog

NVC Case FE Review note

Hi everyone, my family and I are under the F3 category and we just received a notice from NVC that our documents have been approved and that we are Documentarily Qualified. My only concern is this message that we received today in addition to the acceptance: ​ " [Name of petitioner] does not meet the minimum income requirement to sponsor the intending immigrants for this case. The consular officer will make a decision regarding this requirement at the time of the interview. For more information, please visit . To avoid delays, an additional Affidavit of Support Form I-864 for a joint sponsor may be submitted." ​ We already have a petitioner and a household sponsor (the household sponsor's income is above the required level), but still unsure why we received this. Has anyone else received this message? All of our documents say "Approved" on NVC. Does this mean we have to find another sponsor? Can we show the consular officer our

What is the DS-160 form and how do I fill it out?

The DS-160 form is a vital document that every individual applying for a United States nonimmigrant visa must complete. Whether you're planning to visit the U.S. for tourism, business, or any other purpose, this form is a crucial step in the visa application process. Here, we will guide you on how to fill out the DS-160 form effectively to ensure a smooth visa application journey. Firstly, it's important to note that the DS-160 form is an online application, so you'll need a stable internet connection to access and fill it out. Begin by visiting the U.S. Department of State's official website and locating the DS-160 form. Once there, carefully read through the instructions and gather all the necessary information and documents before starting the form. As you navigate through the DS-160 form, you'll encounter multiple sections covering personal information, travel plans, family details, work history, and security-related questions. It is crucial to be honest and

E3 Visa (Australians)

Who qualifies for the E3 visa? The E-3 visa classification applies only to nationals of Australia as well as their spouses and children. E-3 principal applicants must be going to the United States solely to work in a specialty occupation. The spouse and children need not be Australian citizens. However the U.S. does not recognize De Facto relationships for the purposes of immigration, and to qualify as a spouse you will need a marriage certificate. Read more ...